20 Yummy Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren’t Pie
Explore over 20 delicious Thanksgiving desserts that aren’t pie! Elevate your holiday table with these easy and unique sweet treats.
(This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my Disclaimer for more information.)
You can already picture it— your Thanksgiving dinner table, set with a golden roasted turkey, creamy mashed potatoes, and savory stuffing, it’s going to be quite a sight. It’s the heart of the holiday season, where families gather to give thanks and indulge in their favorite comfort food dishes.
But when it comes to dessert, we often find ourselves stuck in the pumpkin pie vs. apple pie debate. While those classic pies have their place on the dessert table, it’s time to think beyond the pie crust and explore a world of Thanksgiving desserts that aren’t pie.
This year, let’s celebrate the sweet end of our Thanksgiving feast with a delightful twist. Whether you’re looking for something new to add to your dessert table or want to surprise your loved ones with unique flavors, we’ve got you covered. We’ve searched high and low for dessert recipes to bring you a list of more than 20 mouthwatering Thanksgiving desserts that aren’t pie.
Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren’t Pie
From warm, comforting desserts like bread pudding and cobblers to elegant and festive options like cheesecakes and tarts, this list has it all. You’ll find creative takes on seasonal ingredients like pumpkin, apple, and brown sugar, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth after a hearty Thanksgiving dinner.
These desserts aren’t just delicious; they’re also easy to make, so you can spend less time in the kitchen and more time making memories with your loved ones. Whether you’re hosting a big family gathering or having an intimate celebration, these recipes are the perfect way to end your Thanksgiving meal on a sweet note.
Let’s dive into this delectable lineup of Thanksgiving desserts that will have your family and friends raving about your holiday spread. Get ready to savor the flavors of the season and create new favorite desserts that will become a cherished part of your Thanksgiving tradition.
Other Thanksgiving Items You’ll Love:
- Easy Thanksgiving Planner (with a Free Printable)
- Easy Thanksgiving Side Dishes
- Leftover Turkey Recipes
- 5 Fun Friendsgiving Party and Theme Ideas
20+ Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren't Pie
This easy dessert cheese ball looks like a turkey, but tastes much sweeter! Make this to serve with cookies or graham crackers for a festive dessert on Thanksgiving day.
Make a cheesecake with vibrant cranberry topping for an unforgettable Thanksgiving dessert. This recipe is so good and so easy for a festive way to end the meal.
Who could resist a slice of cake that has the flavor of an apple cider donut? This recipe is so good that your family will hope to have room for a second slice
If you love pumpkin pie flavor but want to offer something that is both irresistible and different, look no further than this pumpkin spice rice krispie treat recipe. Kids and adults alike will happily grab one of these after dinner.
This sheet cake can feed a crowd and has the best cream cheese frosting. It is also very easy, so you can work on all of the other sides needed for a feast.
Make this healthy dessert for an indulgent meal. Serve this with fruit, graham crackers or even pie crust squares for a seasonal dish that tastes delightful.
Thanksgiving calls for decadent and delicious desserts. This carrot cake is absolutely loaded with all of the good stuff like nuts, pineapple and raisins for a dessert to be grateful for.
Bring a unique and delicious dessert to your family Thanksgiving meal with this unique coquito tres leches. It is so luscious that everyone will make room for a second slice.
Make this easy dump cake so you can focus on all of the side dishes required for Thanksgiving. This recipe is fuss free and has the best combination of pumpkins and pecans!
This cake is extra decadent! It has layers of pumpkin cake with rich cream cheese frosting. Add macarons to the top for the best seasonal sweet!
You only need one bowl to whip up this beautiful butterscotch cake. Your family will love this after a feast of turkey and all of the trimmings!
Mini pie bites are just the thing to serve after a bountiful feast on Thanksgiving. These bite sized pies give you the flavor you crave without overdoing it.
It wouldn’t be the holidays without a pumpkin roll! This recipe makes it so easy you can make one at home and skip the store bought version.
Bring a bright and beautiful cranberry crumble to the table for an unforgettable Thanksgiving dessert. This recipe has a delectable crumble on the top that pairs perfectly with whipped cream.
This cake is so much fun for the family on Thanksgiving. It looks like a perfectly roasted turkey but is actually a decadent cake. Naturally, it is stuffed with cake cubes and candy for an after-dinner treat to be grateful for.
This cheesecake is perfect for any family gathering. It is ultra creamy, has a bright and vibrant cherry topping and is totally vegan so everyone can enjoy a slice after dinner.
Nontraditional and so yummy! I know you are going to love this medley of apple and cranberry with a delicious crumble topping. It is festive and flavorful for a change of pace from all of the pumpkin desserts of the season.
You only need 5 minutes to make this creamy dip. Add candied pecans to make it festive. Serve with fruit, cookies, pretzels, or anything you like.
Hello! Everything looks good! One question, where is the recipe for the dessert on the 1st 4 pictures of the post? It looks like a pumpkin roll but it’s not the same picture as the one on the pumpkin roll recipe. Thank you!
Hi Lisa! It’s my mom’s pumpkin roll recipe that I’ve never written down for myself. Perhaps, I need to create a new recipe if she is willing to share it. 🙂 Thank you for stopping by. –Brittany